Gridskipper, the bastion of hip urban travel, has for some reasons decided to highlight the benefit of Christmassing in India…without actually saying anything. John Rambow notes:
Christmas in India! What could be wackier? It’s true that Christians make up only a sliver of India’s total population. But in some areas, such as parts of Kerala and Goa, on the southwest coast, their numbers may be as high as 20%. Additionally, cities that were once centers of power under the British Raj, including Kolkata (Calcutta), Bangalore, and Chennai, also have fair numbers of Jesus-loving types, and that means garlands, nativity scenes, and Christmas stars are easy to spot in December.
Yes, what COULD be wackier? Those heathens, always coopting our perfectly benign, semi-secular traditions; what will they do next — buy their sweethearts chocolates on Valentine’s Day? Insane-o!
What disturbs me most about this, though, is not that Rambow is so patronizingly astounded that people in another culture might be Christian and/or celebrate “Western” holidays, but that Gridskipper — which I find generally informative and helpful — moves so far away from its generally palatable tips about occasion- and location-specific to-dos. Why not stick with your formula and highlight the five best places for a Christmas brunch in Delhi or Mumbai, rather than mawkishly marveling about another symptom of globalization?
To fill their void, my picks for making merry in India’s capitol:
1) Wenger’s in CP
2) Pam’s Breakfast & Food Centre (for more egg-based propaganda than you can shake a stick at)
3) Chocolate Wheel in Jor Bagh
4) The German Christmas carnival in Chanakyapuri
5) INA Market, across from Dilli Haat, for any fresh fixing you need to create your own Christmas dinner (even the notoriously hard-to-find jellied cranberry sauce)
(Alternatively, some ideas from journalists at the Hindustan Times, Times of India, and The Indian Express.)
December 27, 2007 at 8:01 pm
I completely agree. Being an Indian, I have always seen Christmas being celebrated here, much before the highly touted “economic boom.” I exchanged presents with friends 20 years back in Jammu, definitely not one of the metro cities of India. (Btw, I love Wengers :D)
January 11, 2008 at 9:31 pm
Hi BT,
My hunch, and the reason for writing what I did, was that lots of visitors to India really wouldn’t have much idea about how or even if Christmas is celebrated in India. My other objective was to get the word out about the joys of plumcake. Still not sure how either goal was patronizing.
The Delhi list all sounds like good times, by the way.